| Rank | First Name | Last Name | Team |
| 1 | Manny | Machado | Orioles |
| 2 | Josh | Donaldson | Blue Jays |
| 3 | Nolan | Arenado | Rockies |
| 4 | Kris | Bryant | Cubs |
| *5 | Miguel | Sano | Twins |
| 6 | Todd | Frazier | White Sox |
| 7 | Adrian | Beltre | Rangers |
| 8 | Matt | Carpenter | Cardinals |
| 9 | Kyle | Seager | Mariners |
| 10 | Maikel | Franco | Phillies |
| **11 | Alex | Rodriguez | Yankees |
| 12 | Anthony | Rendon | Nationals |
| 13 | Evan | Longoria | Rays |
| 14 | Mike | Moustakas | Royals |
| 15 | Jung-Ho | Kang | Pirates |
| 16 | Justin | Turner | Dodgers |
| 17 | Daniel | Murphy | Nationals |
| 18 | Matt | Duffy | Giants |
| 19 | Josh | Harrison | Pirates |
| 20 | Pablo | Sandoval | Red Sox |
| 21 | Brett | Lawrie | White Sox |
| 22 | David | Wright | Mets |
| 23 | Martin | Prado | Marlins |
| 24 | Nick | Castellanos | Tigers |
| 25 | Trevor | Plouffe | Twins |
| 26 | Chase | Headley | Yankees |
| 27 | Danny | Valencia | Athletics |
| 28 | Yasmany | Tomas | Diamondbacks |
| 29 | Luis | Valbuena | Astros |
| 30 | Hector | Olivera | Braves |
| 31 | Yangervis | Solarte | Padres |
| 32 | Yunel | Escobar | Angels |
| 33 | Lonnie | Chisenhall | Indians |
| 34 | Adonis | Garcia | Braves |
| 35 | Jake | Lamb | Diamondbacks |
Fantasy Pros eligibility was used, and players with fewer than 20 games at a position were noted with an asterisk and accompanying acknowledgement of actual games played at the ranked position.
* Alex Rodriguez is the only player who is truly listed as only utility eligible on Fantasy Pros, yet he played some third base last year and may carry eligibility there in leagues with the loosest eligibility rules.
| * | 9 G at 3B |
| ** (Not as 3B on FP) | 4 G at 3B |
