| Rank | First Name | Last Name | Team |
| 1 | Paul | Goldschmidt | Diamondbacks |
| 2 | Anthony | Rizzo | Cubs |
| 3 | Miguel | Cabrera | Tigers |
| 4 | Edwin | Encarnacion | Blue Jays |
| 5 | Jose | Abreu | White Sox |
| 6 | Joey | Votto | Reds |
| *7 | David | Ortiz | Red Sox |
| 8 | Adrian | Gonzalez | Dodgers |
| 9 | Prince | Fielder | Rangers |
| 10 | Eric | Hosmer | Royals |
| 11 | Buster | Posey | Giants |
| 12 | Freddie | Freeman | Braves |
| 13 | Chris | Davis | Orioles |
| 14 | Albert | Pujols | Angels |
| **15 | Kendrys | Morales | Royals |
| 16 | Carlos | Santana | Indians |
| 17 | Brandon | Belt | Giants |
| 18 | Wil | Myers | Padres |
| 19 | Mark | Teixeira | Yankees |
| 20 | Lucas | Duda | Mets |
| ***21 | Victor | Martinez | Tigers |
| 22 | Byung-ho | Park | Twins |
| ****23 | Stephen | Piscotty | Cardinals |
| 24 | Mark | Trumbo | Orioles |
| 25 | Adam | Lind | Mariners |
| 26 | Ryan | Zimmerman | Nationals |
| 27 | Chris | Carter | Brewers |
| 28 | Pedro | Alvarez | Orioles |
| 29 | Mitch | Moreland | Rangers |
| 30 | Ben | Paulsen | Rockies |
| 31 | Justin | Bour | Marlins |
| ****32 | Justin | Turner | Dodgers |
| 33 | A.J. | Reed | Astros |
| 34 | C.J. | Cron | Angels |
| *****35 | Jonathan | Lucroy | Brewers |
Fantasy Pros eligibility was used, and players with fewer than 20 games at a position were noted with an asterisk and accompanying acknowledgement of actual games played at the ranked position.
| * | 9 G at 1B |
| ** | 9 G at 1B |
| *** | 11 G at 1B |
| **** | 10 G at 1B |
| **** | 10 G at 1B |
| ****** | 7 G at 1B |
