| Rank | First Name | Last Name | Team |
| 1 | Buster | Posey | Giants |
| 2 | Kyle | Schwarber | Cubs |
| 3 | Jonathan | Lucroy | Brewers |
| 4 | Brian | McCann | Yankees |
| 5 | Devin | Mesoraco | Reds |
| 6 | Russell | Martin | Blue Jays |
| 7 | Yasmani | Grandal | Dodgers |
| 8 | Travis | d’Arnaud | Mets |
| 9 | Matt | Wieters | Orioles |
| 10 | Salvador | Perez | Royals |
| 11 | Welington | Castillo | Diamondbacks |
| 12 | Nick | Hundley | Rockies |
| 13 | Yan | Gomes | Indians |
| 14 | Derek | Norris | Padres |
| 15 | Wilson | Ramos | Nationals |
| 16 | Blake | Swihart | Red Sox |
| 17 | Stephen | Vogt | Athletics |
| 18 | J.T. | Realmuto | Marlins |
| 19 | Francisco | Cervelli | Pirates |
| 20 | Yadier | Molina | Cardinals |
| 21 | A.J. | Pierzynski | Braves |
| 22 | Dioner | Navarro | White Sox |
| 23 | Jason | Castro | Astros |
| 24 | James | McCann | Tigers |
| 25 | Miguel | Montero | Cubs |
