I personally enjoy their rankings. I found them to be very helpful last year. However, I didn't follow their rankings and free-fell a little too far and ended up with crap for pitching. (But that is my own fault)
They make the looking back instead of looking forward mistake every year... more so than other sites.
I don't agree with you about them not rankings young up-and-comers.
They have Corey Patterson
ranked as the 12th
While this site (fantasy baseball cafe) ranks Patterson as the 21st
At Catcher, they have Victor Martinez
ranked as the 2nd best catcher above Javy Lopez
(who is 8 years older than Victor Martinez) (This site has Javy over Victor)
As far as Teix being ranked 1 spot behind Lee ... while I love Teix as a player, I am not as sold on him this season as other people are and I think that selecting Lee above him is perfectly acceptable.
While I am sure there are plenty of examples of their site ranking older players above younger players, there are also plenty of examples of youth before age. You can always disagree with other people's rankings, but I just don't see the bias that you are claiming.