delux_247 wrote:Most importantly I want a fair league. If you guys think that adding cats like BB, K, CG, and SHO makes it less competitve I will give them the boot.
delux - it really should depend on the makeup of your league. If you add those cats they do bring in a greater degree of luck into play. If you have 4-5 guys in your league who are much more knowledgable about fantasy baseball, it might be a good idea to add those cats in order to get the 5-6 other people more involved since they have a greater chance to do better because of the greater luck factor. If your league is competitive top to bottom - duke it out in the standard 5x5 - may the best man win. Hope that helps.
As for the guy in your league who wants standard 5x5 - is he one of the more active/knowledgable people in your league? More than likely he knows that switching to a standard 5x5 format will help the owners like him more.