Gagne is one of the few closers worth taking relatively early, but unless your points system heavily favors closers, 2nd round seems too early for him. Plus, he showed he was semi-human in the second half last year, which dampers his future value a bit.
I'd say mid-3rd at the earliest. The closer position is deep this year, IMO, with a number of young potential hotshots, guys in their prime, and seasoned veterans all likely to post very solid numbers next year. Personally, I'd let someone else grab Gagne that early and try to grab guys like Nathan, Rivera, and Wagner a few rounds later; guys like Dotel, Izzy, and Hoffmann a few rounds after that; and grab a few undervalued guys like Kolb in the later rounds.
I am the Master. Don't question the Master. Just do what he says and be proud.