I was surprised how little debate there was over Jose Guillen last year. Here is a guy that was never really highly touted, had bounced around never having success, was ditched by Tampa Bay with a horrific slg% if I remember correctly, then all of a sudden he's good in 2003?! And it's not really questioned?
Anyway, it was for good reason because apparently he's good now
Good call on Beltre being debatable. I don't know about anyone else, but I've been waiting for him to break out. It's just that it happened so suddenly and surprisingly that it makes me suspicious