I don't think this is like Arthur Rhodes at all... Rhodes was garbage for most of his career, I don't now why he was expected to do well. I certainly didn't think he'd be worth drafting. Mota is better than him, but still not the elite RP many make him out to be. He'll be decent... but I don't think top 10.
Also, what's wrong with Dotel? He pitched fine, got his K's, and was a solid closer. He gave up more HR's than usual but other than that he was pretty damn good, and I don't expect his HR rate to continue like this. It sounds to me like he's under-rated.
"Jack, will you call me, if you're able?"
"I've got your phone number written, in the back of my Bible."