[quote="Pedantic"]I wouldn't even think about keeping Upton (especially if you count fielding
). I would probably keep Victor Martinez and Renteria over Ichiro and Pedro (if you keep an outfielder, I'd rather have Lee). Martinez should be even better next year and Renteria is decent offensively and defensively at a shallow position, while Ichiro is overrated as usual and I agree that Pedro is on the decline. If you keep Vic and Renteria, you'll have your [b]entire[/b] infield wrapped up, and Gagne, Prior, and Santana is more than enough to dominate the pitching categories, unless it's a four team-league.
I agree with your insight, just disagree a bit with ichiro being overated. He dominates in Singles, Av, OBP, SB, K's. Runs (except for this year) and is also good in Triples and a couple more stats. I like a young Martinez too though. Ich is getting old. How many more years does he have left. Renteria is draftable.