It's true Schilling has been more consistent over the season, but Santana still has the better stats overall for this season.
Santana:
2.76 ERA
0.92 WHIP
18 Wins
6 Losses
1 CG
1 SHO
240 K's
.193 BAA
Schlling:
3.35 ERA
1.09 WHIP
19 Wins
6 Losses
3 CG
0 SHO
177 K's
.248 BA
The stats show that Santana has been a much more dominating pitcher. The only thing Schilling has on Santana is the CGs, but Santana does have the CG Shutout going for him. Santana is just barely under Schilling's win total, while pitching for a team with a much weaker lineup.
Santana's the clear choice, there should be no argument about it.
