everyone is entitled to their own opinion no matter how wrong I guess
Both of your lineups are formidable but I'd seriously doubt you'd win.
If its standard 5X5 than you'd kill me in saves but thats about it. My league doesn't play that boring 5X5 stuff its more like a 10x10 (which I don't necessarily like) in which case there would be serious holes in your team.
Even in a 5x5 I'd make some trades (being that my team is excessivly deep) and acquire a couple closers while still not diluting my core lineup.
In any case my initial point was that while there is a place for players like drew you can easily see that there is no way he would crack my starting outfield lineup unless he went on a dimaggio like streak.
BTW I'm in negotiations to add another second tier pitcher to my team.