Goodwin's minor league OBA was .333, and he was older than Gathright for the majority of his MiLB career. Gathright, at age 22, has a career MiLB OBA of close to .400 so I don't think the comparisons, for anyhting other than speed, are valid. He's stealing more successfully than Goodwin, to boot. And Gathright attempts more steals than Goodwin did.
Bottom line: Gathright has MUCH higher expectations than Goodwin, and rightfully so. He could be better than Crawford in terms of SB's and BA........ but he's a tiny guy (5'10" 175) so his power will be a lot lower probably. Then again, Bret Boone is the same size and weight, so ya never know. He could develop power down the road. All he needs is some roids.
"Jack, will you call me, if you're able?"
"I've got your phone number written, in the back of my Bible."