Huh, I have had them all at one point this year. Currently still have only Dye.
I'd probably rank Dye and Hunter as about even. Dye has the advantage in power, but I think Hunter will be more consistent, and hits the occasional HR.
I will admit that I don't know that much about Patterson, but he was really struggling early, and did NOTHING when I had him, except get moved way down in the batting order. Have not kept up on what he's done since.
'12 H2H season standings:
Team 1 = 140 - 118 - 12, 4 OF 12
Team 2 = 84 - 97 - 9, 6 OF 8