If you already have enough wins to beat him, and are far ahead in WHIP and ERA to the point that he can't catch up with just one starter, I would bench all three of them just to make sure you win the three categories. I would not start Maddux until he gets it together because he could very likely get it handed to him again. Leiter is a shaky pitcher at the best of times and I wouldn't start him in Puerto Rico . Unless you need strikeouts, I would also think about benching Oswalt, because he is playing at a big time batters park in Houston and is pitching against one of the best offences in baseball. There is the possibility that Pujols, Edmonds and Rolen could really bang him up so don't take the chance unless you need to.