Please Tell Me, Which Team Is Better?

[Andy1234]

It is a 12 Team 5 X 5 roto league. Who do you think will do better? And what are your comments about each team.


Team A
C - Charles Johnson
1B - Derrek Lee
2B - Jeff Kent
SS - Rich Aurilia
3B - Albert Pujols
OF - Preston Wilson
OF - Vernon Wells
OF - Juan Pierre
UTIL - Josh Phelps
Bench - Joe Crede, Aubrey Huff, Jay Payton, Ellis Burks

SP - Mark Mulder
SP - Tim Hudson
RP - Billy Wagner
RP - Jorge Julio
P - Wade Miller
P - Javier Vazquez
P - Danys Baez
Bench - Alan Embree




Team B
C - Mike Lieberthal
1B - Carlos Delgado
2B - Ray Durham
SS - Edgar Renteria
3B - Eric Chavez
OF - Lance Berkman
OF - Pat Burrell
OF - Moises Alou
UTIL - Carlos Lee
Bench -Mo Vaughn, Karim Garcia, Toby Hall

SP - Curt Schilling
SP - AJ Burnett
RP - Kelvim Escobar
RP - Antonio Alfonseca
P - Randy Wolf
P - Josh Beckett
P - Matt Clement
Bench - Brian Lawrence, Arthur Rhodes

[davegod2]

Honestly, too close to call....

[Siege1386]

I'd give it to team A with a very close call.

[rotorooter]

close call but i voted A.
better saves and less injury risk in starting pitching.
hitting is neck to neck.

[Tigers in '13]

Gotta go with A on speed and RP.

[Rapps5]

very very close - I too gave the nod to team A

[EugeneStyles]

Team A has a terrible outfield and the misfortune of having 2 DH's on the roster. Also, Team B's starting rotation is a little bit stronger.

[Comp625]

Team B needs help in the Saves department. Alfonseca is out until May and even if he comes back, there's a chance Veres might get to keep his job. I also gave Team A the edge over Team B as B's pitching needs a dose of luck.

[Guest]

I think Team B has a better offense. Starting Pitching is even. Team A has better Closers. I give the edge to Team B.

[The Jury]

Team A. Good starters and good depth - you know injuries will strike.