Pedro Martinez, Orlando Hernandez, Ken Griffey Jr., Barry Larkin, Mike Piazza, and Mike Dejean
Pedro Astacio, Jamie Moyer, Juan Pierre, Carlos Delgado, Scott Rolen, and John Smoltz
Okay right away, the guy upgrades big time at 3b and closer. And possibly 1b, I don't remember who his 1b is. I doubt DeJean will close games for the brewers all season. Larkin is also a throw away player considering he's a has-been and Nomar is on his team.
Banking pn Pudge is obviosuly a gamble, but isn't having Junior in your outfield also one?
The pitching is the sticky part. I don't like El Duque, he's usually not very good in the regular season. And if Moyer and Astacio keep pitching well, they could end up a better pair then El Duque or Pedro.
It seems to me he's trading 3 good players (Piazza, Pedro, Grif) for six. Not bad.
Although, this trade is making my head hurt.