Tejada- .275-30-110-10 (might get up to .280 at Camden)
Giles- .305-28-105-10 (Petco into consideration...I was thinking nearly 35 preseason)
Even with Tejada's position boost, I would rather have Giles and his higher average. What do y'all say? Projections would be very welcome.
These projections seem reasonable to me, but it's still probably not a good trade. What you need to do is take projections for whoever is replacing Tejada at shortstop and add those to Giles' projections. Then take the projections of who you are replacing in the OF with Giles and add those to Tejada's projections. Look at which combination is better and then go with them.