An Iconic Fantasy Baseball Community
Moderator: Baseball Moderators
Absolutely Adequate wrote:It depends on the team. Let's say I'm the Yankees and I've got plenty of money to buy the best players. I don't really need a guy that can go out there and pitch all the time. I'll take Mo, because I know that he's battle tested when it comes to the playoffs.
Now, let's say I'm any other team. I need a guy who will be unbelievable in the regular season to make sure that I make the playoffs. I choose Gagne. Because he's more durable and he's fantastic.
Of course, I think the original question is a bit biased. One of the main reasons for choosing Gagne is his durability. You're throwing that right out the window. It's like saying "who would you rather have for one game in which both are healthy: Ken Griffey Jr or Magglio Ordonez." It's impossible to really answer because the question disregards the fact that Gagne can come in and save games 5 times a week.
jeffc_76 wrote:...Gagne has been impressive but as someone said in another post, nobody knows how he would perform in a pressure cooker situation...
jpbusta wrote:Gagne. Rivera does have some great stuff but gagne is THE CLOSER.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests