Alfonso Soriano and Marcus Giles

[INeedaFavoriteTeam]

I think this was brought up earlier, but I was just wondering how much better or if at all do you guys see Soriano than Giles. In one league I have both Soriano and Giles and someone just offered me Vazquez, Santana and Chacon for Soriano, Brian Giles and Pavano. My pitching is pretty weak and I can slide Giles to 2B and put Konerko, Beltre or Genkins into the util spot once Soriano is gone. What do you guys think?

[Zito is God]

Pavano is a joke so i wouldn't do the trade. however, Soriano has MUCH more speed, better power, less contact then giles.

[INeedaFavoriteTeam]

well its ROTO league and I have

C C. Wilson
1B Sexson
2B Soriano
3B Rolen
SS Renteria
OF Berkman
OF Patterson
OF B. Giles
Util M. Giles
BN Konerko
BN Beltre
BN Genkins

SP Eaton
SP Matt Morris
RP Kolb
RP Herges
P Mulder
P Penny
P Pavano
P N. Robertson
P Oliver Perez

I was thinking by trading away Soriano, I can put Marcus Giles into 2B and shouldnt be that much of dropoff. I can free up my util. spot for Beltre or Jenkins. I can then take Vazquez, Santana to go along with Morris and Mulder and Penny and also have Chacon to add to my saves...... But Brian Giles though....i dunno.

I don't usually have dilemmas with trades...i guess just with this one