tough call - I think you can work backwards with this decision and cross off those with bad matchups:
No way you play Ramirez @ SF and @ COL, so drop his name.
BAL and DET's offenses are on fire right now, so unless you are really big on Meche, Id drop him from the list too.
That leaves Redding Batista and Garland. I like Garland and Redding's matchups the best out of those 3, so thats who Id go with.
If I had to choose just one, Id take Garland.