Don't feel badly. Look at my H2H team:
Combined for .216, 2 homers, 13 RBI, 10 R, 0 SB this week thus far. I drafted this team to at least sweep AVG, HR, and RBI (only took closers, no SPs and send out six closers to try to handle ERA, WHIP, and SV. Would spot start if my closing had bad ERA/WHIP numbers). It hasn't worked out that way, though, because this team is just way too streaky. I'll give the strategy some more time, but it's working out horrificly thus far. 10-10 in two weeks.