I agree that it is a virtual toss-up. However, two things to consider. Beckett's inconsistency derives from being injured(blisters)...Weaver is just plain streaky. Secondly, the Boss didn't pay Contreras all that money to be a middle reliever, so when he get's going Weaver is possibly going to lose his spot unless another Yankee starter is injured or traded. Long story short.....I think I would take Beckett.