I'm surprised neither of you chose Shelby Miller or Julio Teheren.
Those four definitely. The rest depend on the keeper rules. How long can you hold someone? Do salaries increase every season? This is useful when placing a value on Harvey. I have him for $10 next season in my $260 league (+$5 each season). I am likely going to hold him.
This was our first year that we stated we would be changing to keeper league so it's kind of been experimental so far. As far as we have laid out you can keep 6 players every year indefinitely and the price won't change. We have talked about a +$5 each season but as of right now that's not in effect.
And if I may ask why Donaldson? Many people like him as a keeper but I don't see the appeal. I mean I really liked him this year, but wouldn't Billy Hamilton, Shelby Miller, or Julio Teheren have more value in the long run?
Thanks for the input guys!