This is tough but i might do the deal where you giving up Phillips, Sandoval, & Shields. Tulo is elite at a weak position but is always an injury risk. I like Shields which is why this is tough. Bailey can have some clunkers, but maybe this is the year he takes the next step. The only stat Shields is better at is era- the other stats are pretty even- to my surprise.
Sandoval is more easily replaced than Andrus imo. You have Freese and Chris Davis you can plug in at the CI spot. If you put Davis at CI, you can put Werth in at OF or pick someone off the wire. Tulo is a risk but could be worth it. I'd take the gamble and do it.
Please help with mine.viewtopic.php?t=463279