What do you think about these other trades that he offered to me? I basically have a choice of the three. Keep in mind my pitching staff without who I'm giving up consists of Wainwright, Buccholz, Lynn and Josh Johnson. I also stream pitchers on occasion but not too often as we are limited to one FA two-start pitcher per week and are allowed 60 adds on the season. When not streaming or using my own starters with two-starts or quality matchups, I overload my staff with closers (Chapman, Rivera, Nathan, Romo, Soriano).
The first trade is what I already listed (Harvey/Cingrani for Bumgarner/Zimmermann).
Harvey/Cingrani for Bumgarner/Masterson/Medlen
I definitely prefer the first one to this as I'm just not a believer in Masterson pitching at this pace ROS. Don't know how I feel about Medlen, either. Because of how I explained my strategy when setting my lineup, I prefer the quality that Bumgarner and Zimmermann would provide ROS over the quantity of Masterson and Medlen.
Harvey/Cingrani for Bumgarner/Shelby Miller/Medlen
I'm considering this trade simply because of the quality of Miller as a keeper. He should be a stud for years to come, just like Harvey. He's just going to run into the innings cap much sooner than Harvey, so I'd be in a similar situation that I'm in now. However, I'd also be adding Bumgarner and and Medlen.