Trade Upton Profar for Stanton?

[rasto21585]

Do I trade Upton profar wheeler for stanton kipnis?

Well this is my team if it helps. It's a 20 team dynasty league.

c jp arencibia
1b prince fielder
2b neil walker
ss yunel Escobar
3b miguel cabrera
inf evan longoria
lf michael morse
cf norichika aoki
rf justin upton
of carl crawford
util desmond jennings
bn nick franklin
Bn jorge soler
bn evan gattis
bn jurickson profar
bn peter bourjos

sp clayton kershaw
sp cliff lee
sp yu darvish
sp daniel straily
rp sean doolittle
rp mat belisle
rp Jose veras
rp heath bell
p mat thorton
p joe blamton
p Barry zito
bn zack wheeler

[rasto21585]

Bump

[jruffus1]

I wouldn't do it. Too much to give up for Stanton.

[rasto21585]

I wouldn't do it. Too much to give up for Stanton.

But isn't getting kipnis also good for my team?

[redkanefox2009]

I agree that's a ton to give for Stanton, I'm not a fan of Kipnis at all. Stay put.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=462616

[rasto21585]

Bump please

[MadDog36]

I would...Kipnis is solid. Franklin good at SS for you...huge upgrade over blehker. Stanton over Up in a keeper

[rasto21585]

But doesn't profar have more upside than kipnis?

[rasto21585]

But doesn't profar have more upside than kipnis?

[zelts3]

You upgrade at both positions there with Kipnis and Stanton. I am low on Jupton, but he has a ton of potential.....as does BJ who I am also low on. I am not thrilled of Kipnis, but I would rather have him in a dynasty then Walker, but not by a ton. I see avg better for walker, steals and bombs better for Kipnis.

In a true Dynasty, you possibly have the gem in Profar. He is so young and he is going to play a very scarce position.

Stanton getting traded anywhere helps his value, which will probably happen.

Since you have Franklin, you could possibly part with Profar.

I would probably take this trade. You are getting 2 guys that you know what you will get in Stanton and Kipnis. Bombs and steals. You are trading 2 question marks in Wheeler and Profar.....not every prospect is Trout or Harper.

The trade is very fair IMO,so I would basically make this decision based on....Whose career am I more interested in following? Go with your favorite players between the trade since you will be the one hanging out with them on your roster for years to come.