Gio/Pagan for Kinsler....WHIR

[casem2k2]

12 team roto....5x5 r, hr,rbi,sb,obp / w, k, sv, era, whip

Do I make this trade?

I get: Ian Kinsler and my choice between Marco Estrada/Jason Vargas/Jose Quintana/Jon Niese

I give: Gio Gonzalez/Angel Pagan

Do I make this trade?

C S.Perez
C B.Mcann
1b A. Rizzo
2b M.Scutaro
3b E. Longoria
ss D.Espinosa
ci Ad.Gonzalez
mi N.Walker
of J.Upton
of B. Upton
of J.Ellsbury
of A.Pagan
util J.Hamilton
util M.Morse
b g.parra
b M.Moustakas
b Z.Cozart
b Alexi Ramirez


SP G.Gonzalez
SP J.Zimmerman
SP Z.Greinke
SP M.Scherzer
RP J.Nathan
RP A. Reed
P R.Cook
P W.Miley
P L.gregerson
b A.Pettite
b J.Masterson
DL B.Anderson

[MadDog36]

You have Anderson coming back and he's a nice replacement for Gio. I think I would. Huge upgrade at 2b. Marco Estrada

[casem2k2]

anymore help please....

[joeyg2323]

I Def take the trade!

Without Gio you have Zimmerman, Scherzer, Grienke, Anderson, miley and Pettitte Losing Gio isnt gonna hurt much.

Kinsler is a HUGE upgrade at 2b

and plus you get a decent SP at the backend i would take Estrada or Quintana cause either one could have a breakout season, its a risk but i think you can take it on one of them with your Pitching Staff.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=460835

[casem2k2]

So your saying I should count on Brett Anderson? lol