Rizzo and J Upton for Verlander and Crawford?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

16 team league, auction league with 280 dollar cap, keeper league(keep as many players as you want per year), 7x7 roto style with OBP, TB, Holds, and QS as extra cats.

I was offered Chris Parmelee and Justin Upton for MY Justin Verlander and Carl Crawford. I am going to turn this down but what do you think of countering with:

MY Verlander and Crawford for his Justin Upton and Anthony Rizzo? Is that a good offer?

My Team:

C-Castillo(4)
C-Brantly(1)
1B-Howard(14)
2B-Kinsler(34)
3B-Gonzalez(1)
SS-Gordon(2)
MI-Kozma(1)
CI-Reynolds(5)
OF-Crawford(16)
OF-Cain(5)
OF-Boesch(1)
OF-Francouer(1)
U-Alvarez(7)
U-Ibanez(1)
BN-Torres(2)
BN-JD Martinez(2)
DL-Youk(11)
DL-Stanton(40)
DL-Forsythe(4)

P-Belisario(1)
P-Buerhle(4)
P-Burnett(5)
P-Cobb(5)
P-Correia(1)
P-Jackson(4)
P-Hanson(5)
Putz(10)
P-Verlander(40)
BN-Crain(2)
BN-De La Rosa(2)
P-Matusz(2)
P-Feldman(1)
P-Quintana(1)
P-E. Santana(1)
DL-Hanranhan(10
DL-Liriano(2)

[JMR162;]

I love that offer for you. He may not do it tho. Can he afford to lose both?

[kidsilk]

Well he is in second place and has a stacked lineup so maybe.

[kidsilk]

He rejected this offer from me and countered with:

Stephen Drew, Chris Parmelee, and Justin Upton for Carl Crawford and Justin Verlander. What do you think?

[MadDog36]

Sorry you are giving up a decent OF and a top SP for a top OF and too mediocre players...if you can't squeeze more out of him ... i'd basically tell him to sit on it..I don't mean that exactly (but ya know).

[clarkdp2]

I agree with MadDog. If thats the type of trade hes going to keep countering with I would give up. If youre giving up Verlander and Crawford I would expect to get J Upton and another decent player such as rizzo not two mediocre players like what he is trying to push on you.

Please help - viewtopic.php?t=460233