MY ANDREW MCCUTCHEN / JOE NATHAN / CHASE UTLEY FOR HIS .....

[wake n blake]

12 team : R. HR, RBI, BB, AVG, OPS, NSB, W, K, ERA, WHIP , K/BB, QS, NSV

Do I make this trade?
I get: Max Scherzer, Troy Tulowitzki, Carlos Beltran
I give: Andrew Mccutchen, Chase Utley, Joe Nathan

MY TEAM

Wilin Rosario
Edwin Encarnacion
Chase Utley
Michael Young
J.J. Hardy
Andrew McCutchen
Michael Bourn
Carl Crawford
Prince Fielder
Giancarlo Stanton
Desmond Jennings
Norichika Aoki
Ichiro Suzuki
Evan Gattis

R.A. Dickey
Jon Lester
Tom Wilhelmsen
Huston Street
Mat Latos
Jeremy Guthrie
Travis Wood
Joe Nathan

HIS TEAM

Salvador Perez
Billy Butler
Howie Kendrick
Chase Headley
Troy Tulowitzki
Carlos Gonzalez
Jayson Werth
Carlos Beltran
Melky Cabrera
Carlos Ruiz
Alejandro De Aza
Lance Berkman
Jason Kubel
Matt Carpenter

Max Scherzer
Felix Doubront
Sergio Romo
Jim Johnson
Bronson Arroyo
Kris Medlen
Marco Estrada
Wandy Rodriguez
Matt Harrison

[wake n blake]

OR. I WAS OFFERED A THREE WAY TRADE WHERE I WOULD RECEIVE

Matt Harvey
Carlos Villaneuva
Mike Minor
Brandon Phillips
Max Scherzer

for

Price Fielder
Michael Young

Which one is better ? I think I need to improve my pitching..

[stackitup31]

I would probably go with the 3 way trade. You get a ton of value for what you're giving especially with how high people are selling on Harvey now. I'd take the three way and trade off your excess pitchers eventually. Hell you could take the 3 way trade and turn right around and sell pitchers. Who would you need to drop to take the 3 way? that's my only hesitation.

[rjforlife]

Both trades are solid, I just wonder as well who you would be replacing in the 3 way trade.

[wake n blake]

Both trades are solid, I just wonder as well who you would be replacing in the 3 way trade.

Yes well that was my main problem... I think I'm leaning towards the second trade because I receive much more of what I need for less. I'll probably end up dropping Gattis, Betancourt, Hardy, Aoki. But I may just ask for somebody a little better instead of Villaneuva and Minor so I can drop one less person. Do we all think the second trade is more in my favor than the first ? Thanks in advance.