Trade Chase Headley??? WHIR

[thesticks23]

5 x 5 with BB & QS
H2H
12 team league Keeper league (5 players a year)

I was offered Nelson Cruz for Chase Headley... At first I thought this was absurd as Chase will be the better choice cause Cruz gets hurt alot.. But now I am kind of not sure about the idea... Is Cruz and upgrade over alejandro de Aza? Cruz belts out HR's where alejandro does not... i would be inserting middle brooks into 3B who can hit bombs to??? Should i take this trade? Or should i say no and just wait for Will Myers to come up and I get the depth at 3b and a power guy in waiting..

C - Mauer
1b- votto
2b - Rutledge
ss - Zoborist
3B - Headley
OF - A. Gonzalez
OF - Shin Shoo Choo
OF - Alejandro De Aza
Util - Mike Napoli
Ben - Kipnis (until he starts hitting better then Rutledge he is benched)
Ben - Middlebrooks
Ben - Myers

SP - Corbin
SP - Kershaw
SP - Zimmerman
RP - Ogando
RP - C. Janssen
P - I. Kennedy
P - Niese
Ben - Cahill
Ben - D. haren
Ben - Beckett

[miracles716]

I'd take what I could for Headley today, Chase was one of my top 10 bust potential and nothing he's done has dissuaded me of that. When a guy hits 30 hrs in 1,500 AB and then hits 32 hrs in one season you have to raise some red flags there. But I think you could get more than Cruz, maybe someone who actually believes Headley has 30 hr power.


Help mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=459318

[thesticks23]

Any other help with this?

[baegames]

I would consider trading him but I would not take Cruz. There are three players I am very hesitant about:
Nelson Cruz
Ryan Braun
Alex Rodriguez

I am just waiting for the shoe to drop from MLB on the papers they bought from Biogenesis, and all three of those names were mentioned.

Help with mine about 4 catchers.