Page 1 of 1

Big Cargo Deal

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2013 10:16 am
by kb8fan21
I am thinking about making this offer, good deal for me and is it a fair offer?

I give Cargo, Gio Gonzalez, and Mike Napoli

I get Ellsbury, Verlander, and Posey

If needed I can add in Victorino

Re: Big Cargo Deal

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2013 10:22 am
by rjforlife
It's a pretty fair deal and you come out a bit ahead. Posey is easily over Napoli although maybe not quite as much as you think. Despite Gio's slow start, he's close to Verlander but still short. Ellsbury seems to be back to top form, as is Cargo. You lose on this bit of the deal but it's slightly less loss than the other 2 parts. I'd go for it.



Re: Big Cargo Deal

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2013 10:32 am
by ant92
I dont like it. If i had cargo i would keep cargo. He's been hot since the beginning of last season so i see no reason to trade him. Sure, Verlander is clearly better then Gio but Gio is no joke on the hill. The only player i see as an upgrade is Posey obviously but he's not going to make up for what you lose in cargo. Napoli will provide some pop at least. If anything i say try to acquire ONLY Posey, instead of the three

help please?

Re: Big Cargo Deal

PostPosted: Wed Apr 24, 2013 10:38 am
by kb8fan21
Thanks guys, I am in a points league head to head. I know Cargo is the best value in this trade but Ellsbury has alot of value because Runs Hits XBH and SBs are big point adders. Home Runs only count for 1 pt, so besides home runs and some more RBIs, i do not see much of a difference between Cargo and Ellsbury in the end.