Such a tough pick, I'd almost have to go with Cano at #4... since he's the top 2B (a safe 100,30,100) with .350-380 obp
I'd go Cano/Fielder/Votto/Pujols - love Fielder's high OBP and should have top 5 power #'s this year w/ lots of walks. Votto has 4 straight .400 obp years, if he's healthy he's an MVP candidate. Cano is the safest, Votto has the highest ceiling... I think Fielder is a combo of both. Damn Pujols is cracking all of them in rankings, hitting in front of Hamilton will benefit.
Just close your eyes and pick, you can't go wrong lol