In my league, we start a 3B, 1B, Util, and CI. Categories are HR, RBI, Runs, Ave, OBP, 2B, 3B, SB, and hits.
I have Fielder, Longoria, Zimmerman, Middlebrooks, and Prado to play CI, 3B, 1B, Util.
I am planning on 1B - Fielder, 3B - Longo, Util and CI - Middlebrooks and Zimmerman.
A guy has offered me:
Butler for Zimmerman and Greg Holland (I won't keep Holland anyway). While Zimmerman is arguably more valuable than Butler because of 3B, I really don't need Zimmerman at 3B. I am going to play Zimmerman at utility.
So...the question is...Will Butler outproduce Zimmerman this year? If yes, I think I have to do it. Right?