Need to keep 8

[poolagoo]

Austin Hedges
Cory Spangenberg
George Springer
Miguel Sano
Alen Hanson
Brian Goodwin
Trevor Story
Trevor Bauer
Dan Straily
Hak Ju Lee
Mike Olt
Jorge Bonaficio
Joey Gallo
Yordano Ventura
Carlos Martines
Bruce Rondon
Jonathon Singleton

If possible, please rank in order , otherwise just pick 8. Thanks for your help. 5 of these players (Olt,Lee,Martines,Rondon, Singleton) I am looking at in trade , of the players I currently have I'm keeping:

Sano, Gallo, Bauer, Straily, Hanson, Goodwin, Springer, and ??

I have Greinke who I cannot keep but can trade so am deciding if it is worth it to dump him for either ROndon/Singleton or two of the Lee/Olt/Martinez trio.








16 team H2H points league
5 major league keepers
8 major league keepers
1 "rookie" keeper

Robinson Cano
Jose Reyes
Miguel Cabrera
Ryan Braun
Jared Weaver

Yu Darvish

George Springer
Brian Goodwin
Miguel Sano
Alen Hanson
Joey Gallo
Trevor Bauer
Dan Straily




Scoring System

Singles 1 point
Doubles 2 points
Triples 3 points
Walks (Batters) 1 point
Hit by Pitch 1 point
Home Runs 4 points
Runs 1 point
Runs Batted In 1 point
Stolen Bases 2 points



Scoring for Pitching Categories

Walks Issued -0.5 points
Complete Games 5 points
Earned Runs -1 point
Hits Allowed -0.5 points
Hit Batsmen -0.5 points
Holds 5 points
Innings 2 points
Strikeouts (Pitcher) 1 point
No-Hitters 5 points
Saves 10 points
Shutouts 5 points
Wins 10 points

[lane_anasazi2]

Austin Hedges
Cory Spangenberg
George Springer
Miguel Sano
Alen Hanson
Brian Goodwin
Trevor Story
Trevor Bauer
Dan Straily
Hak Ju Lee
Mike Olt
Jorge Bonaficio
Joey Gallo
Yordano Ventura
Carlos Martines
Bruce Rondon
Jonathon Singleton

[poolagoo]

Interesting, Story and Ventura I hadn't thought of as serious contenders for those spots. Gallo I thought of as a must keep, same with Carlos Martinez. So...why Ventura/Story over Gallo/Martinez? And thank you for the response.

[Goatrider]

For Sure:

George Springer- could develop immense power along with a defensive game that sticks in the Bigs
Trevor Bauer- pedigree alone
Mike Olt- He's going to be starting soon for somebody
Straily- Already here
Sano- Beastly (maybe of course)

Next:
I'd double up on the SS
Love Hansen and he will be underrated coming into Pitt with no one blocking his way
Story- real deal and O'Dowd has to see rebuild soon. Which means this could be the guy displacing Tulo in Coors

Last:
I'd choose between Singleton and Martinez. I like Martinez much better than Ventura. But the Cards do have a TON of arms and who knows what is going to happen.

I'd go Singleton over Gallo. Gallo seems so far away and people seem to be souring on him. His defense is attrocious meaning he isn't beating out Beltre or Olt for the job. Maybe he shifts to first where the value is much lower. To me Gallo had DH only written all over him, if he even makes the bigs.

Thanks for the help on mine!

[HOOTIE]

Sano is the best imo.
No love for Rondon?
He is nasty, and will close soon.

[poolagoo]

Alright never heard back from Rondon owner so I took Gary Sanchez, Mike Olt, and Carlos Martinez for Greinke.. who I couldnt have kept anyways. Here is what I have, I keep 8 .

Miguel Sano
Mike Olt
Alen Hanson
Joey Gallo
Gary Sanchez

Trevor Bauer
Dan Straily
Carlos Martinez


I'm leaving out

Brian Goodwin
George Springer
Trevor Story
Jorge Bonaficio
Corey Spangenberg
Austin Hedges
Yordano Ventura


Any mistakes you see with going this way?

[Element]

Gallo is kind of ways away. A lot could happen between now and then. I would lean toward Springer over him. Love the rest of your list.