Well, although I was told I had the best team again by many people, injuries and ridiculous things happened and I am sitting out of the playoffs of a 10-team league.
The league has 3 keepers and I have 1 keeper for sure in Miguel Cabrera.
I also have Carlos Gonzalez, Madison Bumgarner, Roy Halladay, and James Shields that are my other worthy keepers.
Now because I am out of the playoff hunt, I figure I can trade CarGo along with 2 of the pitchers to a team in the playoffs in return for an elite player like Braun, Trout, Hamilton, etc... that I will keep for 2013.
If I do this, I figure Halladay will be 1 of the pitchers...who should be the pitcher I keep. Bumgarner or Shields?