WHIR Trade for Mccutchen

[Kempire]

I have been offered to receive Mccutchen in exchange for Ian Kinsler, James Shields, and Papelbon.

Here Is My Team:
C-Buster Posey
1B-Prince Fielder
2B-Brandon Philips
3B-David Wright
SS-Asdrubal Cabrera
2B/SS-Ian Kinsler
1B/3B- Miguel Cabrera
IF-(Empty)
OF-Colby Rasmus
OF-Hunter Pence
OF-Michael Bourn
OF-Matt Kemp
Utility-(Empty)
Bench-Dustin Pedroia
DL-Giancarlo Stanton

SP-Clayton Kershaw, Cj Wilson, Yu Darvish, David Price, Johan Santana, Adam Wainwright, James Shields, Jarrod Parker

RP-Papelbon, Casilla, Nathan, Clippard

DL-Dan Haren

My team is has been a little tricky lately because Pedroia, Haren, and Stanton have all gotten hurt.
I am currently playing with the IF and Utility position open because i do not want to drop an Jarrod Parker, Shields, or a Closer.

Should I make this deal?

[crash525]

Keeper league or re-draft?

[Kempire]

keeper

[crash525]

I'd do this in a second. Does the guy you're trading with have a serviceable MI-type guy that he can throw in now that he is getting Kinsler? I'd go for that.

[Kempire]

he has kelly johnson... i think i could get a little more out of this deal because he has bonifacio coming off the DL.

[warbird1]

Yes do it...andrew could be a top 10 player next season

[ZiggyZiggington]

Thanks for your help on mine.

Id do it man, Mccutchen has been a godsend for me this season, the best guy you are losing is Papelbon but the Phillies can't hardly get him to the mound this season. Mccutchen will be a huge player the rest of the way, and a keeper for seasons to come.