How the heck did you end up with CarGo, Upton, Grandy, Stanton, Craig, Reyes, AGone, Kinsler and Encarnacion in a 10 team league? That's insane. I assume its your keeper rules, but my god you're stacked. I would imagine your sitting pretty each week in the offensive categories despite Upton and AGone's struggles.
As for your question, yes, I'd deal some of your offense for a pitcher. However, with where you're at I'm not sure I'd zero in on a target. I'd probably shop around your entire team for an SP. Just go to your leagues message board or trade block and let them all know you're looking for a top tier SP and that you're willing to trade anyone on your team. See what offers you get and go from there.viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449830