Page 1 of 1

Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 1:26 pm
by BigLen22
This would be a huge deal for me and from a quick glance and over looking the numbers im thinking i win this trade, am i right? with the team i have below that you can see do i do it?

First off most importantly this keeper works as if you draft a guy in 5th round this year next year he is your 3rd round pick.

I get :
Andrew Mccutchen (would be a 2nd round pick if kept)
Lance Lynn(would be a 21st round pick if kept)
Joe Nathan(would be a 17th round pick if kept

I give
Jay Bruce(would be a 4nd round pick if kept)
Zach Grienke(would be a 2nd round pick if kept)
Justin Smoak(would be a 18th round pick if kept)

For me the biggest thing is i was about to drop smoak so getting a top closer is pretty awsome for him. Both MCC and Lynn are outperforming the guys im giving up and Lynn would be a huge steal as a 21 round keeper

Accept or Decline

P.S leave link ill help


12 Team League-Keeper- 10x9(hitting/pitching stats)
C-Carlos Ruiz
1b-Pablo Sandavol
2b-Jose Altuve
3b-David Wright
SS-Mike Aviles
OF-Jay Bruce
OF-Alajandro De aza
OF-Tori Hunter
Util-Michael Brantly
Util-Alcides Escobar
B-/Justin Smoak/Carlos Quintin
DL-Nick Markakis(DL)
SP-Felix Hernandez/RA Dickey/Zach Grienke/Johan Santana/Brendan Morrow/Dan Haren/Ryan Dempster/Aaron Harang/Ted Lilly(DL)
RP-Fernando Rodney/Ryan Cook
DL-Drew Storen
**Only 2 DL spots allowed

Re: Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 1:33 pm
by yankees25
I would for sure do that, that will be a big help for you in the long run.

Re: Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 1:40 pm
by kaiser
I think it is a lot closer than the first respondent, as Grienke is a monster and Bruce is a superstar in the making. But I think you do com out ahead here, so I would say yes, make the deal.

Re: Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 1:42 pm
by BigLen22
thanks kaiser i agree with you. I just see it as Mcc>Bruce, Grienke has been a little worse than lynn but odds are he will be better by end of year but the keeper factor in lynn puts lynn over him. and smoak is worth nothing really to me and i get a top notch closer

Re: Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 2:12 pm
by st3v3k4hn
BigLen22 wrote:thanks kaiser i agree with you. I just see it as Mcc>Bruce, Grienke has been a little worse than lynn but odds are he will be better by end of year but the keeper factor in lynn puts lynn over him. and smoak is worth nothing really to me and i get a top notch closer

Totally agree...

Re: Huge Trade Greinke+ for Mccutchen+(WILL HELP)

PostPosted: Fri Jun 15, 2012 2:39 pm
by jbird669
st3v3k4hn wrote:
BigLen22 wrote:thanks kaiser i agree with you. I just see it as Mcc>Bruce, Grienke has been a little worse than lynn but odds are he will be better by end of year but the keeper factor in lynn puts lynn over him. and smoak is worth nothing really to me and i get a top notch closer

Totally agree...


+2 - thanks for the help on mine.