I think you dominated the trade. Starlin Castro has Dee Gordon's speed but can actually hit too, and he isn't being threatened with getting sent back to AAA. Kinsler is a major upgrade over Kipnis, and losing Beachy hurts but if you're dominating pitching I would value what you gain back in offense.
I'm quickly becoming a Dee Gordon hater...i drafted him 2 leagues to get me SB, and he hasn't even done that in more than 2 weeks. Also, I'm a Cubs fan, but Castro is proving he is legit and will be for several more years.
help? - viewtopic.php?f=26&t=447324