Ok, I don't know if this ranking was delivered yet, but this is the accurate ranking, in case you were wondering.
The spaces are used to indicate tiering.
Good offense (when everyone's healthy), and in my mind he's the true ace of that staff. Won't have as much of a limit this year (possibly no limit at all).
2. Anibal Sanchez
3. Jake Peavy (yes, he's back)
Not as high on Hellickson as most, and I like McCarthy more than most.
In my mind, those two are the same pitcher. One day they could throw a no-hitter, the next they could get absolutely shelled. That's how inconsistent they are.
These two aren't terribly great options...I'm not sure what this list is for, but if you're looking to cut/deal then these two would be candidates, as would the previous two. The previous two of course would bring back something slightly more intriguing probably.