Ethier for Jimenez?

[allen730877]

I was offered this trade in a 12 team H2H Dynasty League but I feel that it isnt enough. Ideas and thoughts on the trade offer appreciated. Thanks in advance.

[MashinSpuds]

Well no, do not do this. Ethier clearly has more value this year and probably in the future, for who knows if and when Jimenez bounces back to his Colorado form. If Ethier gets out of LA into a better ball park or lineup, he could be even more valuable than Jimenez (though his ceiling isn't Hamilton-like by any means). You would need a better piece than Jimenez or another piece with Jimenez to make it worth your while in a dynasty league.

[jackie hayes]

Which side are you? I'm not buying Ubaldo at any price, Ethier side wins in a landslide for me.

[joeyg2323]

jimenez is horrible!!!1 even when he started 15-1 i think it was? he was effectively wild which doesnt usually last. his not a great pitcher his an ok pitcher.

[allen730877]

I of course am on the Ethier side.

[clarkdp2]

If your on the Ethier side then pull the trigger. Jiminez is trash I was hoping he would have another good outing tonight to follow up last sundays start againist texas to try and get some trade value out of him but of course he fives up what 7ER 9H 5BB in 4.1 IP tonight. If you can make this deal hit accept as soon as you can

help me out please viewtopic.php?t=446714