Grenkie for Gordon and Josh Johnson?

[im137matt]

SHould I do that deal? I could swap out Gordon for Chris Davis or Sale. I think I would pick Gordon. It's a H2H keeper league. with the following scoring.


Each SINGLE earns
1 points

Each TRIPLE earns
3 points

Each GRAND SLAM earns
8 points

Each RUNS SCORED earns
1 point

Each STOLEN BASE earns
2 points





Each WIN earns
10 points

Each SAVE earns
8 points

Each INNING PITCHED earns
2 points

Each SHUTOUT PITCHED earns
15 points

Each NO HITTER PITCHED earns
50 points

Each WALK ALLOWED is
-1 point




Each DOUBLE earns
2 points

Each HOME RUN earns
4 points

Each RUNS BATTED IN earns
1 point

Each WALK earns
1 point

Each CAUGHT STEALING is
-1 point


Each LOSS is
-5 point

Each STRIKEOUT PITCHED earns
1 points

Each EARNED RUN GIVEN UP is
-1 point

Each COMPLETE GAME earns
10 points

Each HIT ALLOWED is
-1 point

Each HIT BATSMEN is
-1 point

[NikkiSixx]

It's tough losing Greinke but Gordon is red hot right now and I think Josh Johnson will end up being just fine. It's not what he's done so far, it's what I expect him to do from here on out. Thats the mentality you need to have with Johnson, I would probably take this deal if I were you.

[im137matt]

I already traded Johnson to this guy and he wants to trade him back, it would be easier if JJ wasn't getting rocked.

My Roster is:
1B Adam Lind
C Mike Napoli
DH A.J. Pierzynski
DH Michael young
SS Elvis Andrus
2B Robinson Cano
OF Justin Upton
OF Matt Holliday
OF Nick Swisher
3B Edwin Encarnacion/Chipper Jones
P Adam Wainwright
P Zack Greinke
P Matt Moore
P Craig Kimbrel
P Jordan Zimmerman
P Aroldis Chapman

[ramble2]

I like this deal as well. I like Johnson. Moving forward, he and Grienke could be pretty comparable, and getting Gordon to boot is nice. Personally, I would not buy on Davis.

Help with mine?