Page 1 of 1

Bruce/J. Zimmermann for Reyes/Wandy, WHIR

PostPosted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 3:58 pm
by ILoveBush
12 team yahoo standard Roto.

My team
Wieters, Hosmer, Kendrick, Bautista, Hanley, McCutchen, Bruce, Gardner, Butler and J. Montero
Bn - Moustakas, Fowler

Greinke, J. Johnson, J. Zimmermann, Mike Minor, K. Jansen, Motte, Farnsworth, Pestano, Broxton, Marshall, Reed


I was offered Reyes and Wandy Rodriquez for Bruce/Zimmermann. I generally like getting the best guy in the deal, but I like Zimmermann, I'm already then on SP and there is injury risk with Reyes.

Should I accept? Or counter with a deal that takes Zimmermann out and puts in a RP like Marshall?

Post link and WHIR.

Re: Bruce/J. Zimmermann for Reyes/Wandy, WHIR

PostPosted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 4:19 pm
by lane_anasazi2
I would pass. In a vacuum it's a fair deal, I'd say, but with you starting Hanley at SS I'm not sure how much you're actually upgrading. And you can't really afford to lose J-Zim when your #2 SP is Josh Johnson.

Re: Bruce/J. Zimmermann for Reyes/Wandy, WHIR

PostPosted: Thu Mar 29, 2012 6:55 pm
by MaudDib
If you needed SS help then maybe I do this deal but since you don't, there is no good reason to do it. It would just cause you to trade something else for a pitcher so you might as well keep the up and coming OF along with an up and coming SP.