2b for closers (WHIR!!!!!)

[Holein1]

Regular 5x5 roto team Currently i have Betancourt, Valverde, Johnson and Marshall for my closers. I like to keep 3 closers at all times. My team needs average.

I get

Broxton
Neil Walker

I give

Betancourt
Aviles


My team

Soto
Hosmer
Kinsler
Tulo
Wright
Cozart (MI)
Lind (CI)
Belf
Morrison
Stubbs
Rasmus
Pence
Mayberry (U)
Pena (B)
Aviles (B)

Hanson
Zimmerman
Luebke
D Hudson
Morrow
Nolasco
betancourt
valverde
J Johnson

Matuzs (B)
Niese (B)
Sanchez (B)
Marshall (B)

[HOOTIE]

No, Betancourt is a good closer.
Broxton is a maybe, and he won't be as good as Betancourt if he gets the job.

[GiantsFan14]

No, Betancourt is a good closer.
Broxton is a maybe, and he won't be as good as Betancourt if he gets the job.

yup. betancourt put up some sick numbers last year, i'm buying into him.

[exm]

Thanks for helping me. Betancourt > Broxton, so don't make the deal

[MaudDib]

No deal. Broxton isn't a closer and even if he does get it, he isn't a very sure thing.

[SecretAgentMan]

Stick with Betancourt and pass on the deal. It is not like Neil Walker is Pedroia either.

[mikekim2121]

I like the Betancourt side. He's already a closer and he's better anyway. Neil Walker is better than Aviles but I dont think he's good enough to make up for the difference of a closing Betancourt vs a non closing Broxton.

I think that "a bird in the hand is better than 2 in the bush" saying is applicable here

[kvh_1fan]

I'd stick with Betancourt and Aviles. Aviles and Walker should be close in ranking this year.

Help:
viewtopic.php?t=442214

[midwestpatsfan]

as stated by everyone else, no trade here.


help me please?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=442220