Fade2White12 wrote:In all fairness, that last quote incriminates me.
But there's no need to get nasty here. You'd think this was a money league or something.
Whoops my bad
Most Accurate MLB Experts Past 4 Years
Return to The Brushback League
Moderator: Fade2White12
Fade2White12 wrote:In all fairness, that last quote incriminates me.
But there's no need to get nasty here. You'd think this was a money league or something.
Matt_Domsic wrote:
Look I can quote things too - and they all point to you being a passive aggressive dick
RedBullVodka wrote:I like Fade's proposals.
Sliding scale for escalation of keepers.
Option to keep players for as long as you like.
Good for you if you manage to accumulate lots of top round picks - can't see any way of preventing this if you keep players for as long as you like.
Third Day wrote:RedBullVodka wrote:I like Fade's proposals.
Sliding scale for escalation of keepers.
Option to keep players for as long as you like.
Good for you if you manage to accumulate lots of top round picks - can't see any way of preventing this if you keep players for as long as you like.
I agree with RBV, although I would be open to some sort of penalty if you keep multiple first round picks. Or that you can only keep one player per round, no round sliding.
Ender wrote:On average only 6 of the top 15 players return top 15 value each season. 1st round picks are still pretty fungible in value. I don't have any kind of problem with someone keeping 5 1st round guys because in reality 3 of them aren't going to return top 15 value anyway.
Looking back at 2008 here are the top 3 players per position as rated by the cafe.
VMart, Martin, McCann - Only 1 would have been kept and is a 4th round value
Pujols, Howard, Fielder - 2 would have been kept at good value
Utley, Phillips, Upton - Only 2 would be kept none 1st rounders
ARod, Wright, Cabrera - Only 1 first rounder
Hanley, Tulo, Rollins - only 1 first rounder
Holliday, Soriano, Guerrero - Only 1 worth keeping
Santana, Peavy, Webb - none worth keeping
Papelbon, KRod, Putz - Only 1 worth keeping
In just a 4 year span 10 of the top 24 players by position would have fallen off of keeper lists completely and only 4 would still be 1st round values. The turnover in baseball is a lot faster than people think it is.
Return to The Brushback League
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests