Who is better, Cintron or Loretta?

[afromangettindrunk]

i have both!

[Hoser, eh]

Why is no one else addressing the fact that it doesn't make a difference which shmoe you pick when you got A-rod AND Soriano.

[Mighty Monks2]

I do have a-rod and soriano, but also ensberg who could start platooning at anytime and everybody needs to have bench players. I had Loretta, but someone in my league needed a 2B, so he offered cintron for him. I thank everyone for their thoughts and picked up cintron. HE will be a decent backup for ensberg if he gets hurt, and if he does well, he might be able to take Bradleys place at the Utility spot.

C-Kendal
1B-Sexson
2B-Soriano
SS-A-rod
3B-Ensberg
OF-Berkman, Crawford, Kearns
Utiltiy-Bradley
BN-Cintron, Burell, N. Johnson

SP-Mussina, Beckett, Morris, Webb, Lohse, Pavano
RP-Rivera, Benitez, Julio, Riske, R. Wagner

[DavidiusRex]

Cintron. Much bigger upside IMHO. I'm more likely to think Loretta was a bit of a flash in the pan and Cintron is on his way up. Position eligibility helps too.

[whitesox04champs]

i dont expect too much from loretta this season and cintron is a question mark..............


I would go with CINTRON

[LeftyQB]

How the hell did you get A-Rod and Soriano?

[Mighty Monks]

I drafted a-rod with the #1 pick, and I traded Boone, Sabathia and Nen (the guy was very high on nen and needed closer badly) for soriano and lohse. Great deal for me I think

[rlee]

IMO, Cintron is a no brainer. His upside is much greater than Loretta. He's batting 5th this year which will give him more RBI chances. If there is even a question, his 3B eligibility gives him the nod.

I'm not sure Ensberg is the real deal, especially with Jimy Williams' reputation for platooning. Cintron covers you if Ensberg tanks this year