I would probably do that deal. Longoria is a better player, but they really aren't that far apart. Longoria went 14th in my draft today, and Stanton went around 24th, he almost went 19th (i passed on him for Tex).
Cuddyer for Maybin evens out the deal. I think you get the edge with Cuddyer, plus having Maybin and Gardner in the same lineup, think you'd rather go with Cuddyer/Stanton
This is an even deal, if you are hesitant, don't do it, its not one of those trades thats a No brainer either way.
I'd give the slight edge in your favor, but I also think Stanton's ceiling is higher than Longorias, question is this the year he blows up????viewtopic.php?f=29&t=441510