Without knowing if this is a redraft or auction league, it's not so cut and dry, in my opinion. However, Phillips and Andrus make the most sense, based on position scarcity alone.
It's a 5 man keeper league (forgot to mentioned it is H2H). Only difference in the league this year as opposed to the first three seasons of it is that there are only 10 teams this season, which might make it a more open field.
With my team being stacked in season one I was actually told to drop Sabathia & Braun for other players going into season two. I dominated in every batting category that season and then traded for pitching, which helped to secure the championship. Last season I just ran into a hot team when my team had cooled down.
Appreciate the consensus you all have given me. Going with Andrus & Phillips to round out my five as suggested.