I am in a 14 team roto league (standard 5X5 with OBP instead of Avg). We get to keep 6 total players (one of the players must be rookie eligible).
We have keepers due in the next week and I am debating on a current trade offer of the following:
*two late round picks
*3rd round pick (after keepers)
*8th round pick
Currently, my keepers are Kemp, J. Upton, Strasburg, Lincecum, and Trout (rookie player). The options for my last keeper are: Santana, Napoli, Pence, Uggla, Konerko, and Freeman.
My plan was to keep Santana as I feel he could be especially strong in this format of OBP instead of Avg.
But the trade offer is interesting enough to make me wonder if keeping Napoli, Pence or Uggla (least likely) is not that much of a downgrade from Santana and would enable me to recoup some of the draft picks I had traded last year to win the league. I currently only have 8 picks in the first 10 rounds.
Any thoughts would be appreciated on these key questions:
*How would you rate my keeper options?
*Would you do the trade?