Am I Giving Too Much for McCutchen?

[rasto21585]

In my 20 team dynasty league, I originally offered my bautista and jurrjen for mccutchen and king felix. The other owner rejected and countered with his mccutchen and felix for my bautista cliff lee. I don't know if its worth it to make this trade. I do like a lot how i am getting younger and mccutchen solidifies my OF. What do you think?


--------------------
20 team h2h dynasty league

c j.p. arencibia
1b prince fielder
2b neil walker
3b evan longoria
ss yunel escobar
inf jose bautista
lf carl crawford
cf cody ross
rf justin upton
of peter bourjos
util ryan theriot
bn brandon allen
bn jerry sands
dl jose tabata
dl zack cozart



sp clayton kershaw
sp cliff lee
sp jair jurrjens
sp aaron harang
rp jason motte
rp javy guerra
ry matt guerir
p matt thorton
p jason ingrnhausen
p scott downs
bm jenry meijia
bn blake beaven
bn jason hammel
bn matt harrisson

[jruffus1]

I would not trade Bautista and Lee for McCutchen and Felix. As long as Felix is on the Mariners, he'll never get any run support.

[kaiser]

Dang, that's a tough one. I see Bautista and MCutchen as reasonably equal in terms of keeper value. That's leave it between Lee and Felix. As keepers, I would take Felix.

Make the deal and cross your fingers!

Help here? Votto or Longoria?
viewtopic.php?t=436016

[ahcryky]

This is a trade that I look and it's just basically a toss up. I would really like it if Felix pitched for anyone but the Mariners, I'm just not really seeing any difference but McCutchen giving you some speed, but drop off in HR's.

[rasto21585]

Bump please

[HOOTIE]

Easy deal for me. The key is age and dynasty.
I like Lee and Jose a lot. but

AM 25
Felix 25
Jose 31
Lee 33

You get 6 years of AM and Felix before they hit Jose age now.

I would never trade AM and Felix for this in a keeper.

[dannahann]

Easy deal for me. The key is age and dynasty.
I like Lee and Jose a lot. but

AM 25
Felix 25
Jose 31
Lee 33

You get 6 years of AM and Felix before they hit Jose age now.

I would never trade AM and Felix for this in a keeper.

I couldn't agree more. This is a steal in most keeper setups, in a 20T dynasty it may well end up one of the most influential trades ever made. Take the counter offer before someone else gets wind that McCutchen and Felix are available.

[rasto21585]

does it make a difference i am currently in first place.

[BUCCOFAN]

I am obviously a big Cutch fan, however I think you are giving up too much, Bautista will still qualify as a 3B next season.

PLEASE HELP ME:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=436101